Pros and Cons of Asphalt and Metal Roof Shingles

Are you ready to replace your old roof but don’t know which material to choose? The suitable roofing material depends on your budget, the pitch of your roof, and your sense of style. We’ll share the pros and cons of two different roofing materials to help you choose.

Asphalt Composite Shingles

The most popular roofing material used in America for over a century, asphalt shingles, is made of fiberglass and hot asphalt.

Pros of Asphalt Shingles


Since these shingles are the most popular roofing material in America, they are readily available everywhere. You won’t have to wait on any lengthy deliveries or find out they’re out of stock.


These tiles have maintained their popularity for so long since they are incredibly cheap. They remain so cheap because the petroleum-based raw materials price remains stable, and there is enough to fulfill the demand. If the demand does increase, manufacturers can take steps to reduce costs effectively. If you’re on a tight budget, asphalt is the way.

Cons of Asphalt Shingles


Asphalt shingles are not the most durable options on the market. They can last a maximum of twenty years, while other options can last more than fifty years.

Wind Damage

Asphalt shingles get damaged by periods of high wind and storms. If you are worried after a storm, ensure your roof gets an inspection. That way, you’ll know if tiles were ripped off before the roof leaks.


Growing Mildew or fungus is the most significant problem regarding asphalt shingles. Mold grows on your shingles, specifically the ones in the shade. Molds are always present in the air. They thrive when they find the proper moisture and shade conditions. You must have your roof professionally cleaned or clean it yourself regularly.

Metal Shingles

Metal shingles aren’t as popular as asphalt shingles, but their hype is growing due to being more environmentally friendly.

Pros Of Metal Shingles

Energy Efficiency

Metal roofs reflect the sun’s light instead of absorbing it. That means they do not heat the house as much as other roofing materials. You can spend a little less on cooling since your house will already be a few degrees cooler.


Metal shingles are durable. They have warranties lasting fifty years and can last up to seventy. That means you get great value for your money. If you wish to invest in something that will endure the test of time, metal shingles are the ones for you.

Environmentally friendly

Metal Roofs are Environmentally friendly since they are 100% recyclable. That means you can rest at ease that your decision was right for the planet.

Cons of Metal Shingles


Metal shingles are two or three times the cost of other roofing materials. They aren’t the first choice if you are on a budget.


Metal roofs also make a lot of noise during rain storms. Some people like the sound, but some find it dreadful.


Now you know the pros and cons of asphalt and metal shingles. We hope this helps you choose between the two. While one is better for the environment but more expensive, the other does the job while being cheaper.